Choosing an ecommerce platform: Shopify, WooCommerce or custom?

How Australian businesses should choose between Shopify, WooCommerce, website builders and custom development: start with how you sell, check the local details, and compare the real cost of running the store.

"Which ecommerce platform should we use?" is usually the first question an Australian business asks when it wants to sell online. It is the right question, but it gets answered the wrong way round. People compare feature lists and monthly prices. The better approach is to describe how your business actually sells, then pick the platform that fits.

This guide compares the realistic options for an Australian small or medium business: Shopify, WooCommerce on WordPress, the all-in-one website builders, and custom development. It explains which one fits which kind of business. We have built stores on several of them and advised clients on the rest. We review this guide every twelve months. The date at the top shows when it was last checked.

The short answer

  • Under a few hundred products, standard shipping, no trade pricing, and you want to run it yourself: a hosted platform such as Shopify is usually the fastest and safest start.
  • Content matters as much as the shop (guides, recipes, projects, a blog that brings in search traffic), or you want full ownership and flexibility: WooCommerce on WordPress.
  • A handful of products, alongside a simple brochure site: the ecommerce features in Wix or Squarespace can be enough.
  • Your ordering does not fit a normal cart: products configured to measure, trade and retail pricing on one site, ordering tied into your stock or accounting system. Look at custom development, often built on top of one of the platforms above rather than from scratch.

The rest of this guide explains how to tell which group you are in.

Start with how you sell, not with the platform

Before you look at any platform, write down honest answers to these questions. They decide the choice far more than any feature comparison.

  1. How many products, and how many variations? Twenty products is a different job from 5,000 products with sizes and colours.
  2. Who buys? Retail customers only, or trade and wholesale customers too, with their own prices, credit terms or minimum orders?
  3. Is anything made to order or configured? Cut lengths, custom sizes, engraving, bundles, quotes before purchase.
  4. How does it ship? Standard parcels through Australia Post or a courier, or bulky freight with zones, depot pickup or delivery booking.
  5. What does it need to talk to? Xero or MYOB, a point-of-sale system in your shop, an inventory or ERP system, a CRM, a marketplace such as eBay or Amazon.
  6. Who will run it day to day? You, a staff member with no technical background, or a developer on call?
  7. How important is search traffic? Are customers looking for your products by name, or do you need content that answers their questions?

Most businesses find that one or two of these answers rule out half the options straight away.

The options compared

Shopify WooCommerce (WordPress) Custom development
Best for Straightforward retail stores Content-led stores, full control Unusual ordering, deep integrations
You look after Products and content Products, content, updates, hosting Products and content (with a developer on call)
Running costs Monthly plan, plus paid apps Hosting and maintenance, plus paid extensions Hosting and ongoing development
Flexibility High, within Shopify's rules Very high Unlimited
Content and SEO Good Excellent As good as it is built
Leaving later Possible, but redirects and apps need care Easy: you own everything Depends on who built it

Shopify

Shopify is a hosted platform. You pay a monthly subscription and Shopify looks after the servers, security, updates and checkout. You manage products, orders and content.

Where it shines: it is quick to launch, hard to break, and has a very good checkout. Shopify Payments works in Australia, supports Apple Pay and Google Pay, and buy-now-pay-later options such as Afterpay are available. There are apps for Australia Post, Sendle and most couriers. For a straightforward retail store, this is often the lowest-risk choice.

Where it pinches: much of the functionality comes from third-party apps, and each one usually adds a monthly fee. Five or six apps can cost more than the plan itself. Some things, such as the structure of your web addresses and parts of the checkout, cannot be changed on the standard plans. Shopify also adds its own transaction fee on top of the payment fees if you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments. B2B and wholesale features exist but are limited outside the higher plans.

WooCommerce on WordPress

WooCommerce is a free plugin that turns a WordPress website into a store. You host it yourself, or with a host like us, and you own all of it: the code, the data and the design.

Where it shines: it does content and commerce equally well. If your store benefits from buying guides, project pages, recipes or how-to articles, WordPress is very hard to beat for search traffic. Extensions are available for Stripe, PayPal, Afterpay, Zip, Humm, Australia Post, Xero and wholesale pricing. And because nothing is locked down, almost anything can be customised. Around 80% of the websites we look after run on WordPress, which says as much about how flexible it is as anything we could add.

Where it pinches: you are responsible for updates, security, backups and hosting quality. A WooCommerce store on cheap shared hosting with forty plugins will be slow and fragile. One that is properly hosted and maintained is not. Plan for ongoing care from the start instead of finding out after the first plugin conflict.

Wix, Squarespace and other website builders

All-in-one website builders have added ecommerce in recent years. For a business that sells a small range alongside its main website, such as a café selling gift vouchers or a consultant selling a book, they can be perfectly adequate and very cheap to run.

They become limiting once you need larger catalogues, detailed shipping rules, integrations with accounting or stock systems, or more control over search. Moving off them later usually means rebuilding the store, so think about where the business will be in three years, not just at launch.

Magento, BigCommerce and the enterprise end

Larger catalogues and complex B2B operations sometimes justify heavier platforms. Magento (Adobe Commerce, or the free Magento Open Source) is extremely capable but needs a specialist developer and serious hosting. We built the store for Mister Shelving and Sheds on Magento 2, with Stripe payments and a shipping integration that needed extensive customisation to give customers flexible delivery options for large products. That is the kind of job where the extra weight pays for itself. For most small businesses it does not.

Custom development

"Custom" rarely means writing an online store from nothing. More often it means a standard platform with a custom-built piece where the business does not fit the mould.

A good example is Robot Building Supplies, a Melbourne building supplier with seven stores. Their customers order roofing flashings made to their own dimensions. No off-the-shelf cart handles that well. We built a visual flashing ordering system into their WordPress store. Customers design their own flashing on screen, pay for it instantly, and the order reaches the business with every detail needed to make it.

Consider custom work when:

  • Products are configured or made to measure, and a standard "choose a size" option cannot capture the order
  • Trade and retail customers buy on the same site with different prices, credit terms or approval steps
  • Ordering has to connect to an existing system, such as stock, an ERP or a quoting tool, and an off-the-shelf connector does not exist or does not do the job
  • The ordering process is a competitive advantage, and making it easier than your competitors' is the point

The Australian details that catch people out

Whichever platform you choose, check these before you commit:

  • GST. Prices shown to consumers must include GST, and tax invoices need to show it correctly. Most platforms handle this, but it has to be set up properly.
  • Payment options. Australian buyers expect cards, PayPal, Apple Pay and Google Pay. Many also expect buy-now-pay-later options such as Afterpay or Zip. Check that the ones your customers use are supported, and what each one costs per transaction.
  • Shipping. Australia Post rates by weight and size, flat-rate zones, courier options, click-and-collect and freight for bulky items all work differently on each platform. Test real orders to real postcodes, including regional ones, before launch.
  • Accounting. If your bookkeeper lives in Xero or MYOB, make sure orders, refunds and fees will reconcile cleanly. Fixing this after launch is much harder.
  • Consumer law. Returns, refunds and warranty information need to match the Australian Consumer Law. A template written for the US market will not.

Moving an existing store

If you already sell online, changing platforms is mostly a data and search problem, not a design one.

  • Map every old product and category address to its new one with permanent (301) redirects. This is the single biggest factor in keeping your Google rankings. Our SEO basics guide explains why.
  • Move customers and order history, not just products. Repeat customers expect their accounts to keep working.
  • Plan the cutover for a quiet week, and keep the old store available, not public, for a while in case something was missed.

What it really costs

Compare platforms on the total cost of running the store, not on the advertised monthly price. Over three years, add up:

  • the platform subscription or hosting
  • the apps or extensions you will actually need, and their monthly fees
  • payment and transaction fees at your expected sales volume
  • design and build
  • ongoing updates, fixes and small changes
  • the time you or your staff will spend running it

Shopify and WooCommerce often come out much closer to each other than people expect. Usually the fit with how you sell is what decides it.

Questions people ask us

Is Shopify or WooCommerce better for SEO? Both can rank well. WooCommerce gives you more control and is stronger for content-led stores. Shopify is good enough for most product-focused stores, provided the product pages are written properly.

Can I start on a website builder and move later? Yes. Expect to rebuild the store rather than move it. Keep your product data tidy in a spreadsheet from day one and the move will be much easier.

Do I need a developer at all? For a simple Shopify store, often not. For anything involving integrations, trade pricing or a migration from an existing store, an experienced developer will save you money compared with fixing it afterwards.

Which platform do you recommend? The one that fits how you sell. We build on WordPress with WooCommerce and on Magento, and we build custom ordering systems. We would rather tell you a Shopify plan is all you need than sell you a build you do not.

Getting help

If you are weighing up a new store or a move from your current one, our free website review is a good start. A real person looks at your current site and how you sell, and tells you plainly what we would choose and why.

When you are ready to build, our Websites & Ecommerce team designs, builds, hosts and looks after online stores for Australian businesses. One team does all of it, so nothing gets lost along the way.

Is your website getting you found, and getting you leads?

Get a free website review from a real person. We’ll tell you whether Google and AI search can find you, why visitors aren’t enquiring, and what to fix first. No obligation. Or just call. We answer the phone.

Get a free website review 03 8899 7868 Melbourne based. Working with clients right across Australia.